Counseling Buyers In A Multiple Offer Market

Is it just me, or is counseling your buyer on writing a winning offer a bit stressful?

They want answers to things like “how high should I go” that you can’t answer. And price is just a portion of the conversation. That one seems easy compared to the waiving of contingencies that is going on right now.

So how do you counsel buyers, and feel like you are representing and protecting them, so that they are successful?

Here are some things you can do to counsel your buyers for success:

  • Don’t apologize for the market. The reality is that for many of you, your buyers are competing against escalation clauses, waived financing and inspection contingencies and more. Yes, it’s a lot to ask of a buyer, but it is the way the market is. You didn’t create it. Your job is to position your buyer in the best possible position to be successful in it. Honesty, while uncomfortable, is definitely best in the long run.
  • Every buyer comes to terms with the market in their own time. The honest truth of the current market is a lot for a buyer to wrap their head around. They might not be willing to “go there” on their first offer, because while they trust you, it all seems a bit insane. Let it go. How they write the second offer will tell you if they are ready to truly get in the game.
  • Shift your mindset to “My buyers win on their first offer.” It’s possible. Make it so.
  • Help your buyers set boundaries for each house. Have conversations about under what terms is it the right house for them, and at which point are they comfortable letting someone else have it. It’ allows them to feel empowered no matter what the outcome.
  • Don’t underestimate the power of a well packaged offer. Did you email over 15 different attachments that the listing agent has to compile and dig through to determine what your clients are offering? Or is it all neatly packaged with a letter from the lender, a love letter from the buyer and a summary sheet highlighting what makes their offer amazing? Sellers and listing agents are looking for the easy “yes” to stand out. Make it easy for them to say yes to you.

Properly counseling clients is about giving them the information that they need to be successful, and then letting them make the decision.

Yes, you can absolutely bond with them over the fact that some of this stuff is just crazy, but it doesn’t change the market. So have a good laugh, and then get down to business.

Your clients will appreciate the value that you bring, and you will be much more successful in our offer negotiations.

To your success!
Nicole

Leave a Comment





Signup to receive Nicole's blog posts via email weekly:

Other Posts

What If Your Income Didn’t Depend On The Market?

April 10, 2026

There are multiple markets occurring right now – in the same cities, on the same streets. Sellers are experiencing it one way. Buyers are experiencing it another. And agents? All over the board. Same market. Completely different results. So what’s the difference? What you believe. What you look for. And how you show up. Two…

Permission To Fall Apart: The Truth About Resetting Your Energy

April 3, 2026

What if your next breakthrough is on the other side of your next melt down? There’s a side to energy and mindset work that no one talks about. Most teachings only talk about being positive. As in – ignore whatever you truly feel and pretend everything is amazing in hopes that you eventually believe it.…

I Stopped Waiting For The World To Change… That’s When Everything Did

March 27, 2026

I cringe when I look back at the things I used to believe about my business. Things like: For a long time, I believed these things were true, and out of my control to change. Until I learned how powerful energy and mindset are when applied to business. Here’s what my business looks like now…

I’m The Agent Who…

March 20, 2026

How you finish that sentence predicts your year. What you say creates your story, which becomes your belief. It determines your results and your experience of the world. The things you focus on, how you chose to view them – it’s all part of the recipe that creates your life. Some of you are reading…

When The World Gets Noisy

March 13, 2026

Markets like thismake or break agents. Now, more than ever, your success is determined by – What you believe – How you show up – Owning your value. Are you just trying to make it work with everything going on in the world? Hoping to find clients with the courage to move? Or Are you…

3 No Cost Ways To Attract Clients

February 27, 2026

This week we are going tactical. Good energy gets you in the right space to work with clients. But how do you actually find them? Here are my top 3: When we are slow, it’s easy for our confidence to dip, and when that happens we hibernate. Just like the flowers in spring, it’s time…

I See Your Doubt, A Message To My Younger Self

February 19, 2026

The year has officially begun. New listings are popping up everywhere. I haven’t sold anything yet. It’s common for my year to start a little slow. My business typically ramps up in April. In the past, my confidence would tank as I compared myself to others. This year is different. Some of this comes from…

The Neuroscience Behind Proof It’s Working

February 13, 2026

I’ve been talking a lot about finding Proof That Things Are Working in your daily life. Deliberately looking for moments where things are working out has a powerful effect on your energy, mindset, and the results you achieve. And it is backed by neuroscience. When we look for the good, it trains your brain what…

What To Do When Everyone Else Is Winning – And You Aren’t

February 6, 2026

First, I’d say – you’re being way too hard on yourself. It’s more likely that you’ve had wins, and missed them. This came up in my Proof It’s Working (PIW) group this week. What do you do when it feels like nothing is working, and you don’t see any wins? Step 1: Redefine what Proof…

Do Something Today Your Future Self With Thank You For

January 30, 2026

We assume that success comes in big waves. We search endlessly for the one thing that will unlock the door to whatever it is we want. But, that’s not how success works. Success is a series of actions. It’s showing up consistently. It’s doing what needs to be done. It’s taking care of yourself mentally,…